Yes I think I read that Wildcat review a while back and am now finally reading the book itself so will reread it after that…
There is also an Aufheben review here: https://libcom.org/library/midnight-oil-review-aufheben-3
And a reply from a member of Midnight Notes here: https://libcom.org/library/escape-aufheben-5
Perhaps “lopsideness” is part of a dialectical process? 😉